We know all too well what she’s like as your mother, but what about your narcissistic mother as a grandmother? Will she be a narcissistic grandmother too?
When I had the forum this question came up regularly, and even now I get emails asking me about this very challenging issue, so I share here what we learned/realised through the forum about narcissistic grandmothers.
For some reason society seems to hold the cult of grandmother even higher than that of mother, if that’s possible. Grandmothers seem to be held as sacrosanct, and the grandmother-grandchild relationship as unbreakable.
Daughters of narcissistic mothers therefore agonise: “How can I deprive my child of her grandmother?”, and, “Will my child hate me in years to come for denying her her grandmother?”
Here’s the thing though: the grandmother we are speaking of is not the kindly, rosy-cheeked, apple-pie-making, cuddle-giving grandmother of popular imagery, or even our own imagery.
This is a narcissistic grandmother just as much as she’s a narcissistic mother.
This is, bluntly, an abuser to our children just as much as she was to us. And, for a double whammy, she can use her treatment of our children to further abuse us.
This abuse takes various forms for her grandchildren, just as it did for her children.
She might scapegoat the grandchild, bad-mouthing them, running them down as she did us, dismissing their successes and lives just as she did ours, hurting them dreadfully.
That, believe it or not, is the best option.
The worse option is that she would hijack one or more of our children. I am quite serious when I say this. It happened to so many of the women on the forum, and most of them didn’t realise it till it was too late, and had lost their now-adult children to their mother’s clutches forever.
The narcissistic mother does this by grooming our children. Not sexually, in the way that word is normally used, but grooming nonetheless.
She can start with very young children: the narcissistic grandmother can seduce them with sweets, or toys, or later bedtimes. In a way this is very insidious because the role of healthy grandmothers is to spoil their grandchildren a bit, as a rare treat, in a way their mother can’t do as a way of life. And this works very well for everyone, but only so long as the grandmother is healthy and understands her role is do this as a treat rather than manipulation, to keep it to reasonable levels, and to step back when appropriate.
But the unhealthy narcissistic grandmother can subvert this to undermine your parenting entirely from the child’s earliest days. “Oh don’t mind Mummy, she is so mean not to let you eat sweets before dinner/stay up late/go without washing. I’ll let you do it, but it’ll be our secret, okay?”
What five year old has the sense to realise that’s wrong or to stand up against it? And be sure that your narcissistic mother will do it so subtly and cleverly that you most likely won’t even realise it’s going on.
Then into the teen years the seduction and alienating of your child continues. Narcissistic grandmothers can take advantage of the way teens feel so misunderstood and badly treated by their parents: “Oh I know your mother is horrible to you. Come to me and I’ll treat you much better.” – Of course it would be more subtle and more strategic than that, but that’d be the absolute message. And for the poor angst-ridden teen, that can be so appealing, understandably.
Then, when your children reach adulthood, money can be a bait for them. If your narcissistic mother has money, she might use that to bribe them away from you. And it’s very likely that your relationship with your children might not be great, from their lifetime of being turned against you, so again, this is very appealing. And even if there’s no money, there can be the fallout from the life-long grooming.
The situation can even end up with adult children being fully estranged from their mothers in favour of their narcissistic grandmothers. In this way your narcissistic mother will have literally stolen your children from you. It’s an absolute win for her, because she gets to hurt and abuse you this way, and has other people in her clutches now. What’s not to like, from her point of view?
If I paint a bleak picture it’s because the situation is bleak, and I want to leave you in no doubt of that. I read so many heart-breaking stories from mothers that this happened to. And they all said, “If only I’d nipped it in the bud. If only I’d stopped my children spending so much time with her.”
Narcissistic Grandmothers Are Too Toxic
We came up with a phrase on the forum: Too toxic for you; too toxic for your children.
So, if you ask, “How can I deprive my children of their grandmother?” I say to you: If you keep your children away from your narcissistic mother, you are not depriving them of anything good; you are protecting them from an abuser.
Despite the cultural baggage around the concept of grandmothers, you have the absolute right to protect them from abusers. Indeed, as a parent, you have the responsibility to do so. You wouldn’t let your children go to a house with a known paedophile in it and would feel no guilt or second-guessing about this decision. Narcissistic grandmothers are just as dangerous, in a different way, as a paedophile.
Your child might well ask you, even sadly, “Why don’t we see Gran any more?” Or, if you kept them away from birth, they might hear friends talking about visits to their grandmothers and wonder why they don’t see theirs, and ask you.
You can answer in an age-appropriate way: “Your gran is a very nasty person. She was mean to me all my life, and when you were born she started being mean to you and so we keep you safe by not seeing her.”
Or, “Your gran was a bully to Mummy, so she’s in Time Out until she can learn to be nicer to people and stop being a bully. Unfortunately, she’s not able to stop being a bully so she has to stay in Time Out.”
In other words – explain in your child’s known frame of reference, and your own situation. Comfort your child if she’s sad about the loss – it is totally understandable that she would be, but know that it’s both your right and responsibility to make this decision. Even, your child might be angry at you, depending on her age and how deep the rot has gone. Even so, don’t feel bad for holding to your decision I suggest.
Assuming the rot either hasn’t happened, or is recoverable from, your own relationship with your child can then grow and flourish in a healthy way from then on.
In most cases then, the child will grow up understanding and realising why you had to cut off contact, and there’ll be no moment when she accuses you of denying her her grandmother.
But even if she does. Say, for argument’s sake, that she does criticise you in later life for your decisions now. I strongly believe that even so, it is still the right decision. A parent’s job is to make the hard decisions when they’re the right ones. And if the price for protecting your child from abuse is her later anger at you, then, it seems to me, so be it.
Again, I don’t for a minute think this will happen, if you stop the rot of the toxic relationship before it begins. But I do strongly believe that as parents we still have to do the right thing. Easy for me to say, I know. My own narcissistic mother ignored my son as she did me, and his reaction when (at age 12) I told him he’d never have to see her again, was a literal sagging of shoulders in relief. So I had no risk of this happening at all, so you could argue it’s a bit rich of me to be advocating it.
Also, as ever, I don’t seek to coerce or control any decisions you might make.
I am just sharing the experience of many other women who did experience this situation, and their heartfelt wishes for what they had done differently. In a way it’s not me saying all this to you; it is them.
In summary: you have the absolute right and responsibility to protect your children from abusers, no matter who they are. And if she’s too toxic for you, then your child’s narcissistic grandmother is surely too toxic for your vulnerable precious child.
What About Extended Family?
One big problem is that, if we cut off our narcissistic mother, we risk losing contact with our extended family too. You could of course suggest to the extended family that your relationship with your mother is independent of your relationship with them.
But frankly, that’s not likely to work. The narcissistic mother will no doubt be busy smearing us to the extended family, and forcing them to pick sides, and most of them will pick her for fear of her wrath or rejection or tantrum.
This is horrendous, and horrible, and unfair … but it’s part of the toxic soup narcissistic mothers create for us all to swim in.
If say your sister’s husband was a paedophile, would you let your children play at their house? And if your sister said, “No, I won’t come and visit you without him, it’s all or none of us,” what would you do then?
Your children’s love for their cousins would be important, but their safety even more so.
I’ve no easy answers or solutions for you. I just know that we have to protect our children, and often there’s a high price for that. And it’s so frustrating and I am furious at the injustice of it, for all of us. But that frustration or fury doesn’t change the facts. It’s just yet more fallout of the narcissistic mother’s toxicity. It sucks.
What other DONMs say:
The Mega DONM Resource Bundle
Over $200 of my best resources for immediate download ~ only $37
(Complete no-quibble 60- day money-back guarantee so you can check it out fully and see if it’s for you.)
You’re Not Crazy – It’s Your Mother
The best-selling, life-changing book, now substantially revised and extended.
100 letters of wisdom, warmth, humour, validation, support and encouragement.
Here is what one DONM shared about her experiences with her narcissistic mother undermining her parenting. It shows how insiduous and nasty and clever the narcissistic mothers are, and how we need to be careful.
I was putting something away in the fridge, and I thought I saw a cup with a straw that was half-full with milk. I assumed it was leftover milk from Amanda’s dinner with my mom, and that maybe my mom had suggested Amanda get milk with her meal and then take the leftover milk home. She was always telling Amanda that she should be drinking plenty of milk.
So then I started thinking about how every time we would get together with my mom, Amanda would all of the sudden start acting like something bad had happened or she would whine or cry or seem unhappy, even though she wasn’t doing that before.
And my mom would always look at Amanda with this alarmed, overly concerned face, and she would say “what’s the matter baby?” or just “what’s the matter”, “come to grandmama”, in this voice that made it sound like someone had completely abused Amanda.
Then, my mom would ask Amanda questions that made it sound like she was being neglected. She might tell Amanda that her hair was in her face, and say that her bangs needed to be cut, or was she taking her vitamins, or a whole host of other questions about her care.
I would always feel anxious before our visits with my mom right before this whole charade, and I would get super-defensive once my mom started this whole act. I would work very hard to try and defend myself and let my mom know what I was doing in regards to Amanda’s well-being.
And as always, my mom was half paying attention or ignoring my responses. Now that I know how narcissists are, I realize she was probably truly enjoying creating the chaos and watching me squirm to defend myself and my parenting.
And I always worked so god-damned hard to be on top of everything with Amanda. I’m fairly OCD and very responsible and task-oriented, not that my mom would see that or care.
And, I had my own ways that I took care of Amanda that might not be how my mom would do it, so I’d be busy explaining or defending that.
There was never anything said outright or implied from my mom that I was a good and very conscientious parent to Amanda. She has never once told me that she was proud of me or my parenting.
My mom always brought up only everything that was wrong with anything she could find. Her actions were never ones that showed she thought I was a good parent, and she did all this undermining right in front of all of our faces, especially Amanda.
I didn’t need to uncover anything that went on that was hidden, although that probably was going on too.
She sabotaged, undermined and hijacked Amanda from me, right in front of all of us! And while she let it be known that my parenting was sub par, she was doting heavily on Amanda with over-the-top affection and expensive gifts. Oh how I can see it all now! She always would buy Amanda the nicest gifts for her birthday or at Christmas, and that would leave me trying to figure what I should get Amanda, and the occasions never had that special feeling that you have as a parent where you can dote on your own child. I didn’t look forward to Christmas or Amanda’s birthday.
I didn’t feel like I had ownership of my own child really. And I kept telling myself that it was ok that my mom was doting on Amanda like this, and that it wasn’t about me or my feelings anyhow, it was about Amanda. So whatever feelings I had, I felt were selfish for me to feel.
But now I realize, like always, my mom was taking everything for herself, and that’s only what I knew and how she had trained me.
My life had always been about her. Nothing left for me. There was no “me”.
Now I’m just sad that I feel like my relationship with Amanda could have been so much better during those earlier years, like it feels now. I always felt this wall between me and Amanda, but I just didn’t know any better or how to fix it, until now. Thank goodness I have realized it now though.
Two of the things Amanda said after her last dinner with my mom, that really have stuck out to me, is that Amanda said my mom was behaving poorly because she knows she can no longer control Amanda, and because Amanda is loyal to me (which as we’ve discussed before makes me feel uncomfortable and like I’m being like my mom when I hear Amanda say that, but I do know that thinking is not right because I’m not my mom).
I’ve always said that my mom put Amanda up on a pedestal, but I think it was really the other way around. Everything my mom did with Amanda created Amanda putting my mom up on a pedestal. As a narcissist, she wanted that adoration and loyalty from Amanda. She wanted Amanda to worship her, and she did.
It was about what my mom was getting out of the relationship with Amanda. As we know, kids are the perfect, malleable targets for narcissists. And now that she knows that she’s not going to get that from Amanda any longer, she stopped the whole game, the whole act, and that’s what Amanda was witnessing, and what Amanda was referring to when she mentioned “control’ and “loyalty”.